Michigan kept two doctors from America’s first federal FGM prosecution licensed. The Attorney General’s office wrote memos asking to close their licensing files before the court case ended and won’t release them to the public. LARA engaged in obstruction tactics when I investigated their actions.
However, I am not going forward with a lawsuit against either.
I had planned to. At the time I am writing, GoFundMe for this investigation has raised $3,011. A legal retainer is $5,000. I would have to lose money on this investigation to pursue it further. I decided to spend my own money and go into the red to make it happen.
I filed one lawsuit myself and hired a law firm for the other. Then the firm dropped me due to a “conflict of interest” they did not inform me of until after I had signed a letter of engagement and received a receipt for my retainer. Now, neither case is going forward.
Background: In 2017, federal prosecutors charged Dr. Jumana Nagarwala and Dr. Fakhruddin Attar in a female genital mutilation case. A federal judge ruled the law unconstitutional and dismissed the FGM charges in November 2018. Both doctors still hold active, unrestricted Michigan medical licenses. On July 27, 2018, Assistant Attorney General Bridget K. Smith wrote memos asking LARA to close each doctor’s licensing file. Michigan won’t let the public read them, citing attorney-client privilege.
My first case was against the Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs, or LARA, the agency that licenses doctors, over excessive fees and denials of my records requests. The second would have challenged the Attorney General’s privilege claim to get memos showing why the medical licensing cases were closed. Michigan’s Freedom of Information Act gave me until October 28, 2026, to file it.
For the second case I wanted a lawyer. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press referred me to Brian D. Wassom, a partner at the Michigan law firm Warner Norcross + Judd. I wrote to him on July 2. He replied that his colleague Charles C. Kadado could assist “once he completes a conflict check.”
Kadado and I spoke by phone on July 6. His written summary the next day covered the challenge to the Attorney General’s privilege claim and set a $5,000 retainer. On July 8, I asked Kadado in writing whether I could file the fee challenges myself and retain the firm only if a case reached a hearing. He answered that the firm would consider that kind of limited representation “on a case-by-case basis” after reviewing “the filed pleadings.”
On July 26, Kadado wrote that the firm needed “a signed engagement agreement and the required retainer payment” before it could give me any more help or legal advice. I replied the next day that I wanted to proceed. I asked that the agreement state its scope: the challenge to the two closure memos. If my fee cases fell outside it, I wrote, “I’d like that stated so we both know where the line is.”
July 30 was the last day to file two of my fee claims against LARA. I filed the case myself that day, at 5:54 p.m. Eastern. It is Marotta v. Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs, Court of Claims Case No. 26-000163-MZ.
The same day, the firm sent me its engagement letter through DocuSign, signed by Wassom. Its scope section covers one matter: potential litigation in the Court of Claims against the Michigan Department of Attorney General over the withholding of “two responsive documents.” Kadado also emailed me his analysis of the deadline for that case. I had to file, he wrote, “no later than October 28, 2026.”
The court accepted my complaint on August 3. I signed the engagement letter the same day. The DocuSign certificate for the firm’s envelope records it as completed at 2:00:33 p.m., with a copy delivered to the firm. I submitted the $5,000 retainer through the payment link in the letter and received a receipt.
At 2:08 p.m., I emailed Kadado and copied Wassom and the firm employee who had sent the envelope: “Engagement letter is signed. Deposit paid. Let me know how we get started.”
At 2:12 p.m., I sent Kadado a second email. I told him I had filed the fee case against LARA and the court had accepted it, gave him the case number, and asked whether the limited representation we had discussed for a hearing was something he could take on.
Kadado replied to that second email on August 5. “Unfortunately, during the intake of your file, we discovered a conflict of interest,” he wrote.
He attached a letter, copied to Wassom. It said the firm “must terminate our attorney-client relationship effective immediately.” It stated that I had “signed an engagement agreement and paid a retainer,” and it said the firm would refund the retainer in full. Neither the email nor the letter said who the conflict was with.
On August 6, I sent the firm nine written questions. I asked who the conflicting client was, when that representation began, and why the firm had not found the conflict before I signed. I asked whether anything I had told the firm had reached that client. I pointed out that the engagement covered the Attorney General and my fee case named LARA, and I asked why a conflict over one would reach the other.
Wassom replied at 3:19 p.m. He wrote that my retainer payment had “failed for insufficient funds,” that “the engagement transaction was never completed,” and that there was “nothing to refund.”
I answered the same afternoon and attached the receipt. I wrote that I had the funds and would check for a bank error. I pointed to Kadado’s letter terminating “our attorney-client relationship.”
“The receipt was in error,” Wassom wrote back. “You can verify that $5k did not leave your account. No engagement was formed.”
I checked my account. The $5,000 had not left it, though there was more than enough money in the account to cover the retainer. Wassom’s email was the first time anyone at the firm had told me the payment failed. I had written “Deposit paid” to Kadado and Wassom on August 3, and Kadado’s August 5 letter said I had “paid a retainer.”
In the same email, Wassom gave another reason. The firm “also would have withdrawn from the engagement if there was one,” he wrote. He said I had “filed a pro se complaint, on which we had no input,” on the same day I signed a letter “specifying that we would advise on the possibility of filing a complaint.”
However, Kadado and I had discussed the possibility of the firm representing me in a case I filed myself. On July 8, I asked him in writing about filing the fee challenges myself, and he answered that the firm would review “the filed pleadings.” When I sent him the case for review, the firm’s answer was to terminate a signed engagement.
The engagement letter covered a potential complaint against the Attorney General. The complaint I filed was against LARA, a different agency. I had asked why a conflict over one would reach the other. Wassom did not answer. He also did not say who the conflict was with, when it arose, or what screening was in place.
On November 16, I sent Wassom and Kadado six questions for this article and asked for answers by 5 p.m. Eastern on November 18. Neither replied. Wassom’s out-of-office message said he would be back November 23.
In late August, LARA started using the suit itself to block my records requests. Between August 25 and September 3, it denied four of them with the same paragraph. Each denial said, “Customer has filed suit against LARA.” Michigan’s FOIA exempts records relating to a civil action between the requester and the agency. One of the four asked for emails from September 2017 through December 2018.
To get the memos, I would have to sue the Attorney General without a lawyer. Someone who is not a lawyer versus the literal Attorney General is not a fair fight. While I believe we deserve to win the case on the merits, if I lose, it could set a precedent that those documents get locked up. I’m not going to risk closing the memos, due to lack of representation. October 28 passed, and I did not file.
The case against LARA is gone too. On October 28, I dismissed it. I had not served LARA. I decided it was not worth my time. The most it could have gotten me was money, and I don’t need the money. I want justice. The suit would not have held anyone accountable. If I thought it would create change, I’d pursue it.
I also don’t know what the memos would tell us that the rest of the record hasn’t. The important thing is that Michigan kept them licensed. All that’s going to be on that piece of paper is their stated reason.
At this point, I’ve done what I can. I have put more work into this than everyone whose responsibility this was, like the medical licensing board, medical organizations, and the people’s representatives. I have also done more than the organizations that claim to care about this issue and raise donations on it, like anti-FGM and intactivist groups. All of them have more resources than I do.
Nagarwala’s and Attar’s licenses remain active and unrestricted. The Attorney General’s office still withholds documents explaining why.


